Back to the Blog

Common Mistakes To Avoid When Asking for Donations

A man is holding a glass donation jar in his outstretched hands. The jar is filled with coins and bills.


Donations play a critical role in the success of non-profit organizations and fundraising events. These contributions fuel your mission, enabling you to make a difference in the communities you serve. Asking for donations can be a delicate process, and making mistakes can hinder your efforts. Let’s explore four common mistakes to avoid when asking for donations.

Mistake 1: Not Clearly Communicating the Purpose of the Fundraiser

Failing to communicate the purpose of your fundraiser is one of the most significant mistakes you can make. Donors want to know exactly where their money is going and how your organization will use it. Vague or ambiguous appeals can diminish trust and make potential donors hesitant to contribute.

Offer a transparent and compelling narrative about your fundraiser’s purpose. Detail the problem you’re addressing, the solution you’re proposing, and the impact of the donations. Use specific examples and statistics to back up your claims. For instance, “A $50 donation will provide clean water for one family for a month” is more effective than “Please donate to our cause.”

Mistake 2: Setting Unrealistic Fundraising Goals

Setting unrealistic fundraising goals can discourage both you and potential donors. When goals seem unattainable, donors may assume their contributions won’t make a difference, decreasing their motivation to give.

Set realistic and achievable goals. Break down your overall target into smaller, more manageable milestones. Celebrate and communicate each milestone to maintain momentum and encourage continued support. For example, if your overall goal is $10,000, aim for smaller increments of $2,500 while celebrating each milestone.

Mistake 3: Ignoring the Power of Personal Stories

Facts and figures alone rarely inspire donations. Personal stories create emotional connections, making donors more likely to contribute. These narratives humanize your cause and demonstrate the real-world impact of support.

Share stories of individuals or communities who have benefited from your organization’s work. Use testimonials, photos, and videos to bring these stories to life. Finally, ensure these stories are genuine and relevant, showing donors how their contributions can make a tangible difference.

Mistake 4: Failing To Follow Up With Donors

Focusing only on acquiring new donors while neglecting existing ones is a critical error. Retaining donors costs less and brings in sustained support over time. Following up with donors shows your appreciation and keeps them engaged with your cause.

Send personalized thank-you letters or emails immediately after receiving a donation. Update donors on the progress of your campaign and the impact of their contributions. Also, consider organizing exclusive events or providing special updates for repeat donors. Showing ongoing appreciation ensures donors feel valued and encourages future contributions.

The Importance of Avoiding These Mistakes

Fundraising requires careful planning and execution. By avoiding these common mistakes when asking for donations, you can enhance your fundraising efforts and build relationships with your donors.

At Vertical Raise, we know successful fundraising hinges on transparency, realistic objectives, emotional connections, and ongoing gratitude. We can help you implement these strategies to maximize your football fundraiser ideas or any other type of fundraiser. Get in touch today to drive your mission forward!